1.5lb Skippy Natural Peanut Butter $4

This 26.5 oz jar of Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter drops from $5.63 to $3.74 at Amazon. This jar of peanut butter is more than 1.5 pounds and costs $6.99 at our local grocery stores! Skippy Natural only contains four ingredients, and, unlike other natural peanut butters, you don't need to stir it to keep it from separating. Editor's note: I always have a jar of this on hand for baking because it's not greasy or oily like other natural peanut butters. I never see it priced this low when I'm grocery shopping!